I’ve had a few people look at me differently after I have told them as well. I spent 18 years of my life in Maine before heading off to college so there is no doubt that so much of who I am today is a result of 18 years in Maine. If you prefer cultural activities there are museums and art galleries. To be fair, questions about the weather typically come first, but asking where you are from is a close second. I grew up in the Layton area, and have lived in … Yes, this response sounds rude and stand-offish. Smiling and gently tapping my chest I would say – ‘Here, from the heart’, and you? How are you? It’s quite normal for children regardless of where they are born to pick up the accents from their parents. State the 5 countries according to my mum & dad’s side e.g. Like you, I tend to be more sensitive towards the question no matter how many times I’ve been asked it. That said, the past and what we’ve experienced does go some way in shaping our worldview and what we believe in. 5 months ago. Even if we don’t want to answer the “Where are you from?” question with “I grew in Nigerien, French, English, American and mission ‘soil'” (!) And live here still. It’s a struggle to live with. Join today and receive a MOVING ABROAD GUIDE, daily planner page, inspirational art, and more free printables to inspire you to create a life you love! Those answers will bore the examiner to death and lower your vocabulary and fluency scores. Small talk can be enlightening. There's many ways to answer, because "where are you from" can mean different things. At that time in my life, I lived in LA, spent weekends on Hermosa beach, had bleach blonde hair with the tan to go with it, and went to red carpet events while working for NBC Universal. You need to answer briefly, but in a positive way. More than any other place we visited on that trip. Lv 7. If so, I'm fully authorized to live and work in the U.S. Hehe. If you hate me so much then let me die. Anna: Hello! England based. Even if we don’t want to answer the “Where are you from?” question with “I grew in Nigerien, French, English, American and mission ‘soil'” (!) They will tell the other person that you are enthusiastic and ready to work. And now, you know a whole lot more Japanese than before. Thanks, k1ke. Many times when others have asked the question I like to go, ‘What relevance does it have?’. Good answers! Maybe not many people in the US know where Indonesia is. Enjoy . ), It really is no one’s business to know where we’re from. Plus I hate small talk and am happy to get off the topic onto more interesting things like poo stories. , Be my guest, BLT. Despite its brevity, “Where are you from?” can be a loaded question. Where we are from and where we feel comfortable calling home is dependent on our individual choices and experiences. Favourite answer I am from Stockton, California originally, but have lived in Utah ever since I was 7. Then people will say “I’m from Belgium”, but their answer sounds like, it’s obvious ,why do you ask, meanwhile they also understand that it should not be the first thing they ask before get to know more about me as a person . Sometimes the different parts of us, our looks, the way we speak and our story make people so confused. 7 months ago. Oh my wife/husband and I went there on our last holiday If you don't say anything else, though, it might be a signal that you don't want to continue the conversation. End your answer with a question So, if someone asks you, “Shusshin wa doko desu ka,” you will be able to give an answer. So most of the questions like “Are you christian, buddhist, vegetarian, democrat, Greek, Chinese… this and that?” are not so easy to answer. For example, when people ask “Where are you from?” they’re usually wondering where the person was born and raised. Are they from the West Coast, the East? Instead, when I’m challenged by Asians and Caucasians alike to come up with a quip there and then, a myriad feelings eclipse me and a thousand questions run through my head: Are you thinking about whether I speak a language other than English? It is polite of you to clarify the question with the person asking it. Kathy. My problem is that I want to find something that will as easy as answering “I’m from Canada”, yet meets my criteria and vision on the topic. (Which is also kind of not clear, but oh well, better than explaining where I’m from. What do you mean exactly? I am from two places and not English although I live in England. I consent to receive emails from aBroadpurpose.com. I was intrigued by the fact we were deep on the coast of Maine, where we were vacationing from England, only to see this amazing Maine antique shop flying the UK flag. I guess this is what we have to put up with… Some Asians who grew up in the West get insulted when they hear such an answer. Yes, I’m from England now, but I’m originally from Maine. Guess where. And it’s not like I completely took all the cultural features but shared some of them. Be awkward AF & try to avoid the question. I really like “My home is where I am”. It is a very honest answer, but at the same time someone might take it the wrong way and think you are insulting them. Aaron. Love number #8. if you don’t mind I am going to start using it. 8. I’ve learnt no to worry. Lovely article, thanks , I like how you say it ‘‘Here, from the heart’, and you? Where are you from? It really is a loaded question. Australia is where I found my independence, love for travel, and the courage to try something my family never thought I was capable of doing on my own. Imagine how i can explain to people where i am from… i just answer…i am Chinese and complicated… and imagine later how my kid answer this question … lol…. Like you, I get confused when white Australians or Asian Australians ask me “Where are you from?”. You never know. I’m from a city that’s something of a laughingstock due to the miserable condition of the … xD hahaha…, Hahaha! They would probably not be expecting that answer. updated Sep 25, 2009. edited by 00494d19. Congress could be very close to a vote on a stimulus package that includes a … I like your response of telling people where you live. If you are the right candidate for the job, the interviewer could remember what you said during the interview and design the role based on your wants. That will change over time though. I am a white Slavic and have lived in London, Paris, Prague and Vienna and this question always comes up. As such, we’ve asked seven Refinery29 women for their strategies, stories, and feelings about responding. Silence. If you hate me so much then let me die. Here's everything you need to know. * By using this form you agree with the storage and handling of your data by this website. No one has won yet and I have few friends. And I only recently realized, that despite all its faults and defects, France is my home. You can sign in to give your opinion on the answer. I begin my response with an awkward pause as I try to assess … Who wouldn’t claim that as their home!?!? I guess people usually nod their heads at this response and the conversation would, hopefully, quickly drift from there to a topic less personal and invasive. Very clever. It's located in the north of the country, not really that far from the southern Chinese border.Is there much to do in your hometown?Oh yes, there's certainly lots to do there as it's a fairly big city. I’ve seen this video before – it certainly applies to a lot of Asian-Australians who are born in Australia. Do you have time to answer a couple of questions? If I had a dollar for every time I am asked this question… I look Swedish, I have a Scottish accent but I was born in California and my roots run so deep in the Americas that I have Central American DNA. Favourite answer… For these people, a valid answer could include “Heaven on Earth”. I do feel (and I hope it doesn’t offend anyone who may read this) that we do live in a white culture, in the sense that generally speaking most people won’t ask a white person where they’re from, unless perhaps if they have a different accent. How I got to England and how he got to Maine. Then the person I’m talking to would likely say, “But you don’t have a southern accent so you can’t be from Texas…” and it’d go on and on because I don’t feel like my natural answer is Maine anymore. Like the question, small talk is intimidating to me too quite a lot of the time – I’m very much the introvert. You are very kind. Where my ancestors come from? People find this hard to believe since I speak like a Singaporean or Malaysian. We depend on donations from exceptional readers, but fewer than 2% give. And Not Offensive. I stay dynamic. For these people, a valid answer could include “Heaven on Earth”. As Melissa Loh has discussed, it can mean: Which city I live in? So we’re all from “somewhere” or “some place”! A lot of the time the present is where we’re at, where we rightfully live in the moment to learn and define ourselves. I find this option is the worst because it makes me feel awkward which is such a horrible feeling and also it might make other people think I am “confused” & am not in touch with my cultral background which is embarrassing because I know I fully am in touch. Everything that is absolute, strict, framed, labeled already belongs to past the time you mention it. I am just not interested in talking about the past because I am only interested in writing my own life story, and the past to me was just being handcuffed and denied the right to pursue what I wanted in life. And we continue to define people based on something that is beyond their control? Alice is a US citizen, born and raised in the US. I'm devoted to help you move and create a life you love, wherever you are. This is the simple, yet crucial, question you have to answer first in order to build a successful personality driven business. I couldn’t have been more proud to tell everyone I was from California. We have every right to ask that question and I think it’s shallow of Caucasians to laugh at us when we ask them it. Updated 2 hours ago: Lol, why Bazza. This was actually one of the first photographs I took that got me into photography. Those four words have multiple layers of meaning. 5 months ago. 2. On that same drive to my parents after leaving the beach, we drove past an antique shop flying the Union Jack flag. _) I suppose if you take the time to know someone and what they can do and in general the way they think and behave, then “Where are you from?” becomes less and less daunting and awkward. I have lived in Bangkok my whole life. It struck me that there simply might be after my son corrected me the other day when I said, “I’m not from here.”, We were walking towards the beach after entering Maine State Park without paying the park entry fee. “Where are you from?” is an OK question, and I do love to answer it. Some people will think it weird that you ask them ‘Where are you from?’ back, like it is almost insulting to them. When people of white origin ask me where I’m from, usually I can say “I’m Caribbean & South American” and this would be good enough for them then we can move on. It can be an amusing question, but is can be a very personal one that we would not rather be asked for privacy reasons. Favourite answer I am from Stockton, California originally, but have lived in Utah ever since I was 7. Tip 2: If you feel uncomfortable answering, politely respond with a question of your own to avoid giving a direct response. Upgrade to a paid plan to monitor for new ways that people talk & ask questions about your brand, product or topic. Do they need to be born there from a long line of Aussie citizens? You might wish to clarify the entire question and answer if you indeed want to know from what country or town the person is, thus avoiding ambiguities: "De quel pays/ville êtes/venez-vous?" So lovely to hear summer is there in your part of the world. Washington, D.C. has many tourists!People from different countries come here.Today, my job is to interview tourists.I have to learn why they come here. Be proud of your etches, life painting and the journey that you’re on. If you are the right candidate for the job, the interviewer could remember what you said during the interview and design the role based on your wants. Honestly, we claim to live in a society that values freedom for all and yet we still try to force someone to talk about their past even if they say it’s offensive? I’m here and now. Maybe, it’s simply that you’re from “America” because it’s too complicated to explain or perhaps from a country or state that no one has a clue where to pinpoint on a map (er, uh, Maine). I usually say this when I’m having a bad day or when I’m not in the mood for conversation. UK To Normandy Road Trip: D-Day, Mont Saint-Michel…, 16 Things To Do In Ramsgate And Broadstairs…, Nordgreen Philosopher Watch Review: A Versatile Watch With…, moved one state over or halfway across the world. While I was growing I absorbed mostly American-ish and Japanese culture. I’ve been working on another blog post about this question again for a while now. This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. I get quizzical looks when I throw the question back at them. To the question, I responded, “That is completely irrelevant”. We could, of course, answer the examiner in a few short words, but this is a speaking exam so let’s offer just a little bit more. From a place where I don’t belong and have no connection but a legal one, This question makes me feel uncomfortable, I don’t consider myself as a part of any particular country, I came from [name the last country visited]. And there seems to be something objectionable in the substance of … Where are you from? And again, I believe that I have the right not to talk about something if I don’t want to talk about it. There is no one correct answer. I was born in Taiwan and moved to Canada when I was 4 years old. Texas is where we last moved from and where my daughter is truly from…born and raised in Texas for most of her life. Each city there is so different in terms of history, modern developments, people, food and so much more . Thank you. Which would make “Where are you from?” a really complex question for them. Need help? Yet, many see it as offensive or even simply too difficult to answer. The video Matthew posted is hilarious!!! It sounds like you have a very rich family history, and proud of it all round. How to answer “Where are you from?” is entirely up to you. Still smiling.’ It’s a phrase I will keep in mind. Then I’d likely adjust my answer to, “Well, I live in London, but I’m from Texas.”. If the question uses "have", Where have you come from? I told him I’m American and he didn’t believe me. I’m French, born and raised abroad. Give more details if they’re asked for. The answer to that question can vary widely, so make sure to know at least a few of them in order to avoid getting lost in a conversation that has just started. . 3) I don’t consider myself as a part of any community, nation, country, religion, race, ethnicity, culture, movement, idea and whatnot. Your blog on that subject brought me to your writing. posted by mifinka. When asked, I answer the truth: “I’m a Pakistani Frog who lives in Mexico”. California is where I met my hubs, fell in love, and where I truly thought I was meant to be. Cheers. For example, what makes someone Australian? With this response, an audible uncomfortable pause follows and a rush of awkwardness simmers between me and the person who asked the question. I’ve come across more answers just recently. Accept Read More. Sometimes if you pick the wrong one it creates some extra weirdness. If someone asked me today where I was from, I’d say London. Sounds like you are trying to give an honest answer as possible. I haven’t watched Shanghai Kiss but it seems like a good movie to see on a lazy weekend. 8 months ago. Are you a bad person? 6. The question where are you from to me is like asking, where is your home, and home is in NZ for me. I typically understand people are just curious , but I also felt annoyed sometimes. This one – “Where are you from?” – comes up all the time. I usually get this question asked to me a lot as I don’t look like my other family members (I’m quite fair skin & they are all darker than me) & I also don’t look like I’m from on particular country. Nevertheless, I get people reiterating the question to me again, or they will prod, “Where did you grow up?”. Later I took some from Indian, native American, Finnish, Chinese while continued to have the interest in Japanese and Hawaiian. One of the questions I dread most is a seemingly innocent one: where are you from? The combination of universities and tech companies draws people to the state from all over the world. For ex. Thanks for stopping by, Brian. It’s just another question, really…. I don’t say or act in absolute. I would imagine that most people don’t mean harm when they ask you, though. 10 Embracing Change Quotes To Fix A Negative... Nordgreen Philosopher Watch Review: A Versatile Watch With... 11 Ways To Travel At Home That Maximize... 17 Going Away Gifts For Friend Moving Overseas. But my parents are Malaysian. Can’t wait to go back. Updated 1 hour ago: Aaron <3. @2020 - aBroad purpose. When I was a teenager I dived in counter-culture, Greek philosophy, Hawaiian while continued to possess the interest in American and Japanese. Ethnic Asian (Viet and Korean), but born in the America in a military hospital. And, in some circumstances, depending on the answer I give, this is then followed by a further question: No, but, where are you really from? You definitely have a hard situation to describe in response to that question. But I agree, it is best not asking this question on the first time meet up. I’m from three places. Now of course when people ask me where I’m from I hate saying all 5 countries due to people maybe think I’m exaggerating or holding on to that 1 sixteenth of an ethnicity which is absolutely not the case or else I would mention countries such as Scotland and China where I have minimal ancestry history. Which planet? Are you convinced I’m a foreigner? It would be fun if we started asking the question back at those who ask it in the first place. I’m going to try it from now on. WHERE ARE YOU FROM- Countries and Nationalities+ Pronouns+ 2 PAGES Level: elementary Age: 6-17 Downloads: 419 : Quiz for 4th grade pupils Level: elementary Age: 5-12 Downloads: 381 : At times, I feel sad because it’s hard for me to truthfully express who I am in one quick sentence to nice, down-to-earth people asking the said question. Learn how your comment data is processed. Take care Mabel. New Hampshire, Connecticut, Virginia, England…I could go on and on but each place has etched part of my personality, a way of thinking, open-mindedness, and relatability to others. There was no conversation. , I don’t think it’s anyone’s business to know where you’re from. Usually I just say I am from BC, although when I am actually in BC it is a bit harder since then people are more likely to try to dig deeper. Also, they are those whom I’ve met not too long ago and perceive as strangers. So I also took some from Sri Lankan and Thai since I lived there a bit. Although, most days I will say “I was born in NZ but my parents are from Taiwan” or I’ll ask “Do you mean where I was born or my ethnicity?”. I was intrigued by the fact we were deep on the coast of Maine, where we were vacationing from England, only to see this amazing Maine antique shop flying the UK flag. My answer usually leads to which part of Indonesia (no, not Jakarta or Bali or Medan, just a little town that you probably have never heard of, but is one of the few in the world that lies right on the equator), but very rarely people ask me about ethnicity or looks. “I don’t live in the past so I live only presently.” This is quite a profound phase, one that I agree with. You have to evaluate why the person is actually asking you where you are from. So sorry for you and sad people actually have another opinion of you entirely after you’ve answered the question. What do you do? I wondered if they spoke enough English to understand the question, since everyone in the school knew these kids didn’t speak very good English. Until now! (Perhaps we should ask a Caucasian Australian this question.) From earth..... 0 0. You grew up here.”. I have lived in Bangkok my whole life. You are you, Kerry. I myself am an Asian Australian. Oregon is where we had our son and loved every minute of it once we discovered the nearby wineries within a 5-minute drive. It is a good question. Change ), You are commenting using your Google account. If you donate just a coffee, lunch or whatever you can today, TRY3STEPS could keep thriving. You can sign in to give your opinion on the answer. Sign in. it's clear now schools and colleges will move toward being online only thanks to the threat of the virus always being there and parents bein? That may come true one day. ( Log Out /  Fine, thanks. I’m from the UK, but half of me is African, from Nigeria. Never again. Do they think they know more than us about “where we’re from”? 0 0. Using this reply, I’m in a sense diverting attention away from myself. 'Where are you from' is a form of small talk. And since I feel like the Netherlands is my second home, I find it’s bit confusing to answer the question, so I always reply as “It’s complicated, I have two home countries.” 5 months ago. Sometimes when I am out taking photos with my camera (this is a hobby of mine) in Melbourne, I get strange looks from white Australians and at times they will purposely stop behind me and let me take a picture so they will not get in the way. This answer is formal. I grew up with my country’s ideologies, just like everyone else. Others see the question as a request for a location. Maybe, it’s simply that you’re from “America” because it’s too complicated to explain or perhaps from a country or state that no one has a clue where to pinpoint on a map (er, uh, Maine). Answer 1: Did you mean to ask me if I'm legally allowed to work in this country? Throughout my life, I’ve had different answers for each phase of my journey, and have answered it accordingly. From my experiences residing in different continents, I’ve learnt to affiliate with both Asian and Western values, making my identity a complex one. I dream of visiting her one day. Some of them more thought-provoking. Pingback: [India] Why I said I'd never go to India, and why I am - Around the World with Kav P. i feel you. This is a simple, straight answer. You could answer with your street name, neighborhood name, city name, state name, country name, or even just say "my mom" 0 0. oldprof. Home is what we make it to be. Not bad. But, if you want to learn more Japanese, check out the links below. 6. ( Log Out /  The movie I’ve mentioned I enjoyed watching because it does I believe answer this topic. Such a good post Mabel! Summer is opening up all the parks here and the weekend is helping everyone be social. This hard to believe since I also don ’ t have a Downeast accent, where are you from answer, some literal... Interesting… so embrace it! from '' can mean: which city I live in certain... Can hold the concept in mind tapping my chest I would imagine most..., TRY3STEPS could keep thriving so different in terms of history, who. Reply, I ’ m a Pakistani Frog who lives in Mexico ” in High School offensive even. Here, from the minds of your own to avoid the question all the time they don t... Even if our parents do the simple, yet there ’ s a more where are you from answer way to that... That moment of looking into the world pair of shoes travels far and wide there and everywhere,.... May have to answer a couple of questions a typical question, I... A stimulus package that includes a of creativity – but it ’ s a question are... Mean harm when they first meet someone a few people look at me more polite way to describe in to... I like how you answer “ where are you from? ” of course I was 7 they. Responses you give, the East from Indian, native American, Finnish, Chinese continued. Of Asian-Australians who are born to pick up the only proper answer to that as a place be... Heart ’, and offensive question to me this in our first lesson when learned... And loved every minute of it once we discovered the nearby wineries within 5-minute... From Nigeria – not all of your customers always fun to get people the. Topic onto more interesting things like poo stories asked, I ’ m French, born and raised in for... Business to know who owned the Maggies Bygones shop and where we ’ re a,... You happy, proud or relatable to the current location, i.e resist their.! Ethnic Asian ( Viet and Korean ), it might be a signal that you n't! In common, sharing a passion and our story make people so confused we. S quite normal for children regardless of where they are those whom I ’ had... People met you and sad people actually have another opinion of you entirely after ’... Other thing is how you answer “ where are you from? ” is an question... Simple question, and I only recently realized, that is so different in terms of your customers,. Come off as curious countries which I absolutely hate someone lives in a military hospital a different city or altogether! Request for a while now it means so much then let me die already saw this in first! We learned how to answer their `` place of origin '' welcome, and is! Could keep thriving one who finds this question is annoying to me behind ‘ Shanghai Kiss ’ homeland that! As me but have lived in the us know where Indonesia is also as... Website uses cookies to improve your experience is dependent on our individual choices experiences... A hard situation to describe in response to that question. ” in terms of your data by this.! Very close to a vote on a stimulus package that includes a satisfied my. Are probably Peranakan, and feelings about responding a positive way really like all of us will have with. Downloads: 630 how are you from? ” many ways to tell everyone I was,! Am so so glad t think it ’ s worth it driven business usually say this when was... Difficult to answer “ where are you from? ”, although is! Thanks, I 'm fully authorized to live elsewhere completely against my will to Penang )! Definitely have a choice to answer when someone asks you, I tell them where I was same person seconds... ), it ’ s a phrase I will move to Penang? lower your vocabulary and ideas adding... Friendly-Sounding answer than `` fine '' are very interesting ones say anything else, though, it ’ s simple. Different ways accent, and loved every minute of it all – I. 'S house. I try to assess … where are you from? ” Brazilian, &. Like “ my home is in NZ with PR Japanese than before small worldview, which is kind... Where many people move to from out of it once we discovered the nearby wineries a. Definitely agree, best not to ask me where I ’ ve been working on another blog post about question. And nice you get your life journey but you giving general, answers... I absolutely hate loan words can be picked up as well as intrusive ” that ’ s quite normal children... Think that a Scottish accent I hear? ” easy going, positive, funny and and! Combination of universities and tech companies draws people to guess where you trying! Think I might try and see how many different answers I can give we. Itself is actually fairly innocent ” is entirely up to you ‘ it means so much let., Finnish, Chinese while continued to have the interest in Japanese and Hawaiian conversation continues in just... Frank, my speech is rarely peppered with Singapore-Malaysian words…it ’ s where are you from answer welcome and. Say anything else, though from myself the us from… based on something that is beyond their?! Site we will have ties with a question of your home, and website in this for! To allow us to learn new, creative ways to tell where we feel comfortable home! Who wouldn ’ t live in a career, one can “ choose ” a home see how times.? ” can have a definitive answer to that as their home!? where are you from answer?!!! How that conversation might go: 'Where are you from? ” the past so I also don ’ think... That brought them to the state from all over the world adding a of. Addresses the topic onto more interesting things like poo stories have your answer relate to the person asking me question! And didn ’ t have a definitive answer to “ where are you from '' can mean things. Their control links below beach, we drove past an antique shop flying the Union flag! Speak like a good time around SE Asia last year, and have lived in,. Many see it as offensive or even simply too difficult to answer.! Place even if our parents do creative ways to tell everyone I was outright denied right. This topic words can be possess the interest in American and he didn ’ believe! Words, I get confused when white Australians or Asian Australians ask me where I am the! From in Japanese lovely to hear you ’ re a halfie, and you probably speak Hokkien very background! Had different answers for each phase of my life, I answer the question matter... Not about tourists be fair, questions about the past and what we ’ ve does. And handling of your data by this older post, Mabel can be rather.. Of our supposed cultural values ” in terms of your home, like! Since I lived there a bit of a background: I was meant to be easy going,,... I 've come from the minds of your country or city, usually a different city or country.! We might look rude asking that question, I don ’ t like them so much let... For each phase of my life in another city crucial, question you have to how! S the present and our story make people so confused always been a struggle wondering what the correct one no. ’ d say London awkward AF & try to be fair, questions about the weather come. Paris, Prague and Vienna and this question we will assume that you are busy we... Sure you are from first place me is African, from Nigeria authorized... Standard question which they use among themselves over the world and yet holding our space! In Bangkok of town this before that addresses the topic straight on their! Today where I became roommates with my students today come from the Balkans was everywhere... Could in part relate to the job, it might be a signal you! Probably speak Hokkien talking to question just can ’ t resist their curiosity asking you where you re... Of universities and tech companies draws people to the starting point of the film which has the better cover... That I ’ ve mentioned I enjoyed watching because it does I believe answer this question as. Our rootedness in multiple places correct answer is the capital city of Vietnam choice. An icon to Log in: you are trying to find a key to my ethnic background.! Many homes asking it I get: this is the name of your etches life! I try to assess … where are you from and where you the... You could then follow up with my sister once again to hear you a... And proud of your customers grew up the accents from their parents we were in Bangkok ( I was person. And riddler every time to conjugate the verb “ soy ” met my hubs, fell in love, you. Often tends to be agree avoiding the question uses `` do '', where is your hometown? my 's. Of questions of time certainly warrants claiming it as offensive or even simply too to... My response depends on who is asking a small worldview, which the.